At the heart of any fan community, speculations and rumors can sometimes fuel ongoing discussions, and such is the case with “One Tree Hill” star Bethany Joy Lenz. Drama seems to be brewing behind the scenes of the “Drama Queens” podcast, a show hosted by Lenz alongside her former “One Tree Hill” co-stars Hilarie Burton and Sophia Bush.
What started as a platform to reminisce about their time on the iconic teen drama has recently become the center of some intense online discussions, leaving fans wondering if there is unresolved tension between the cast members, especially between Lenz and Burton. Let’s dive into the details of what has been going on and how it relates to Bethany Joy Lenz.
The History of “Drama Queens” and the Trio’s Bond
The podcast “Drama Queens” became an instant hit as fans of One Tree Hill tuned in to hear their favorite stars—Bethany Joy Lenz, Hilarie Burton, and Sophia Bush—reminisce about their time on the show. Over the years, this podcast grew beyond nostalgia and into a space where the actresses discussed important topics, such as their experiences with sexism and inappropriate behavior during their time on the set.
In 2017, the trio came together with other cast members to sign an open letter accusing show creator Mark Schwahn of sexual harassment and manipulation. The three actresses have spoken candidly about how Schwahn would pit the women against one another, sharing personal stories of how this manipulation played out behind the scenes. These shared experiences seemed to strengthen their bond, or so fans thought.
Bethany Joy Lenz’s Memoir Sparks Drama
Fast forward to 2024, Bethany Joy Lenz announced the release of her memoir Dinner for Vampires: Life on a Cult TV Show, a book that would explore her decade-long experience in an abusive, high-demand group, which she refers to as a cult. This memoir, described as a story of forgiveness and manipulation, quickly became a topic of discussion among fans and even her co-hosts on the podcast.
However, fans started to sense that all was not well between Lenz and Hilarie Burton. On the same day that Lenz announced her memoir, Burton posted a cryptic message on her social media accounts, sharing a quote by Pink that read, “I don’t think imitation is the highest form of flattery. I think it’s annoying.” This raised eyebrows, with many assuming the post was a jab at Lenz’s book, especially given that Burton had released her own memoir, Grimoire Girl: A Memoir of Magic and Mischief, just a few months earlier.
Social Media Unfollows: The Start of Fan Speculation
The rumors began to snowball when it was discovered that Bethany Joy Lenz and Hilarie Burton were no longer following each other on Instagram. While it’s unclear whether they ever followed each other on social media in the past, this revelation added fuel to the fire, leading fans to speculate that the two were no longer on good terms.
TikTok users, particularly @laguna_biotch, were quick to share their theories about the alleged feud, with some claiming that Burton was upset over the similarities between the two memoirs’ cover art. Fans weighed in on TikTok and Instagram, with one commenter saying, “It better not be about a damn book cover because Hilarie’s wasn’t some revolutionary concept.”
A Deeper Look at Fan Reactions
The fallout from these rumors was swift. Many fans took to social media to express their disappointment, with some accusing Hilarie Burton of “bullying” Bethany Joy Lenz. One fan commented on Burton’s Instagram post, writing, “I’m so sad to see what is happening with Joy Lenz. I wish you continued to be an example modeling friendship… the part you made us part of makes it look like you’re bullying Joy. I’m so sad.”
Other fans were simply disheartened by the idea that the tight-knit bond they had grown to love between the Drama Queens might be fracturing. The podcast had brought comfort to long-time One Tree Hill fans, and the thought of the show ending due to behind-the-scenes drama was too much for some to bear. “If they end Drama Queens before getting through the whole series, I am going to be UP IN ARMS,” one frustrated fan commented on TikTok.
The Podcast’s Future
As of October 2024, neither Bethany Joy Lenz nor Hilarie Burton has directly addressed the feud rumors, leaving fans in the dark about the future of their podcast. While both actresses still follow Sophia Bush on social media, the ongoing tension between Lenz and Burton could spell trouble for Drama Queens moving forward.
Though nothing has been confirmed, the speculation and lack of communication between the two stars have kept fans on edge. Could the show survive without one or both of its leading ladies? Only time will tell.
Conclusion
What started as a nostalgic podcast celebrating the sisterhood formed on One Tree Hill has now become a hotbed of rumors and fan speculation. While it remains to be seen whether Bethany Joy Lenz and Hilarie Burton will address the tension publicly, the ongoing discussions have made it clear that their fans are deeply invested in their friendship. As Drama Queens continues to navigate this rough patch, fans are hoping that the actresses can reconcile and move forward, both personally and professionally.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Is Bethany Joy Lenz still on good terms with Hilarie Burton?
As of now, there has been no public confirmation from either actress regarding their current relationship status. Speculation of tension between them arose after Lenz’s memoir announcement and Burton’s cryptic social media post.
2. What is Bethany Joy Lenz’s memoir about?
Bethany Joy Lenz’s memoir, Dinner for Vampires: Life on a Cult TV Show, explores her decade-long experience in an abusive, high-demand group, which she refers to as a cult. It focuses on manipulation, forgiveness, and her personal journey.
3. Why are fans upset with Hilarie Burton?
Fans believe that Hilarie Burton’s social media post, made on the same day as Lenz’s memoir announcement, was a veiled critique of Lenz. This led some fans to accuse Burton of “bullying” Lenz, though this has not been confirmed by either actress.
4. Are Bethany Joy Lenz and Hilarie Burton following each other on social media?
No, as of October 2024, Lenz and Burton are not following each other on Instagram, which has fueled rumors of tension between the two.
5. Will the Drama Queens podcast continue?
The future of the podcast is uncertain, as neither Lenz nor Burton has addressed the feud rumors publicly. Fans are hopeful that the show will continue, but there is no official confirmation at this time.