James Thurman Butts Jr., born on August 1, 1953, is a prominent figure in Inglewood, California, serving as its mayor since 2011. Butts has had an extensive career in law enforcement and has been a key player in some of the most notable transformations within the city, including the development of SoFi Stadium and Intuit Dome. Despite his achievements, Butts’s career is also marked by controversies that have drawn public and media scrutiny. This article will explore Butts’s life, career, and the challenges he has faced.
Early Life and Education
James Butts was born and raised in Los Angeles, California. He graduated from Crenshaw High School and later attended California State University, Los Angeles, where he earned a Bachelor of Science degree. Due to an injury, he missed an opportunity for a basketball scholarship but instead worked part-time at the Inglewood Police Department. This initial role set the stage for what would become a lifelong career in law enforcement. Butts later earned an MBA from California State Polytechnic University, Pomona, further strengthening his qualifications.
Law Enforcement Career
James Butts’s law enforcement career began in 1972 with the Inglewood Police Department, where he served in various capacities. His roles included positions as a SWAT team commander, homicide detective, and undercover officer, where he worked on high-risk cases to reduce crime. He earned promotions throughout the years,
becoming Sergeant in 1981, Lieutenant in 1984, and eventually Commanding Officer of the narcotics division in 1986. As the first African American in the South Bay area to hold the rank of Chief of Operations, Butts led efforts to reduce drug trafficking in some of the city’s most challenging neighborhoods.
In 1991, Butts accepted the position of Chief of Police in Santa Monica, a role he held until 2006. During his tenure, crime rates in the city fell by an impressive 64%. He spearheaded initiatives to control drug activity and crime in Palisades Park by enforcing city ordinances, though his approach drew criticism from some who believed it unfairly targeted the homeless population. His firm stance, however, helped establish his reputation as a tough but effective leader.
Tenure in Public Safety and as Inglewood Mayor
After leaving his position as Chief of Police, Butts became the head of security for Los Angeles World Airports (LAWA) in 2006. He implemented training and disciplinary measures to improve safety, earning LAX recognition as the most secure Category X airport by the TSA in 2009.
In 2010, Butts returned to Inglewood, where he successfully ran for mayor. Elected in 2011, he took on a city burdened by a financial deficit and high crime rates. Butts made significant strides in public safety and economic reform. His first State of the City address emphasized rebuilding the city’s finances and enhancing security. Butts negotiated with unions to revise costly pension agreements and launched infrastructure projects to modernize Inglewood’s facilities.
As mayor, Butts was instrumental in bringing a $100 million renovation to The Forum, a popular entertainment venue in Inglewood. He cut through bureaucratic obstacles to fast-track this project, which reopened in 2014 and became a major hub for concerts and events. Butts also played a pivotal role in the construction of SoFi Stadium and Intuit Dome, projects that revitalized the city and attracted significant economic opportunities.
Controversies and Legal Challenges
Despite his contributions to the city, Butts’s career has not been without controversy. In 1995, while serving as Chief of Police, he was named in a lawsuit for alleged Miranda rights violations. This case became notable as the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that police officers could be held accountable for Miranda violations, despite claims of immunity.
Butts has also been associated with several ethical investigations. In 2018, the California Fair Political Practices Commission, the FBI, and the Los Angeles County District Attorney launched an investigation into a $100 million trash contract awarded to a company linked to Butts’s brother. The probe raised questions about transparency and potential conflicts of interest.
Moreover, the Madison Square Garden Company, owner of The Forum, filed a lawsuit in 2018 against Butts, alleging that he misled them into surrendering land that would later become part of the site for the Los Angeles Clippers’ Intuit Dome. This case intensified public scrutiny on Butts’s dealings with large corporate projects, as critics argued that his leadership style favored aggressive development with insufficient public input.
High-Profile Lawsuits
Butts has also faced legal disputes from former employees. Melanie McDade-Dickens, a former aide and romantic partner, alleged wrongful termination, harassment, and retaliation. She claimed that after ending their relationship, Butts continued to exert control over her work environment and personal life, accusations that have been highly publicized.
Another lawsuit involved Inglewood’s city treasurer, Wanda Brown, who accused Butts of defamation and retaliation. After voicing concerns over city spending, Brown alleged that Butts restricted her speaking time and limited her duties, eventually slashing her salary by 83%. Brown’s lawsuit further cast a spotlight on Butts’s governance style, which some describe as authoritarian.
Economic Development and Inglewood’s Transformation
Under Butts’s leadership, Inglewood has seen a dramatic economic transformation. The construction of SoFi Stadium, Intuit Dome, and other developments have brought jobs, tourism, and revitalization to the city. These projects, however, have not come without criticism. Some residents argue that the developments cater to corporate interests over community needs and have led to increased property values and potential displacement.
Butts’s efforts to make Inglewood a central location for entertainment and sports have undeniably reshaped the city. Yet, these changes have sparked debates over gentrification and whether the benefits outweigh the social costs.
Recent Investigations and Ethics Concerns
In recent years, Butts’s governance has faced increasing scrutiny. In October 2024, Councilwoman Gloria Gray accused Butts of creating a hostile work environment and retaliating against her for supporting initiatives for her district. The councilwoman’s complaint adds to a growing list of ethical concerns about Butts’s leadership approach, which some argue discourages dissent and transparency.
Additionally, Butts was involved in a car accident in 2019, where he collided with another vehicle while driving a city-owned car. The accident led to lawsuits from the other driver, a police officer injured in the crash, and the LAPD seeking damages. These incidents have raised questions regarding Butts’s accountability and personal conduct.
Legacy and Future Challenges
James Butts’s legacy as mayor of Inglewood is marked by substantial economic progress and transformative urban projects. His administration has brought renewed attention and economic growth to a city once overshadowed by high crime rates and financial instability. However, the multiple lawsuits and ethical investigations continue to cast a shadow over his achievements.
Whether Butts’s legacy will be remembered for his ambitious development projects or the controversies that followed him remains to be seen. As Inglewood continues to evolve, the balance between growth and community integrity will be critical in shaping the city’s future.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What is James Butts known for?
James Butts is known for his dual careers in law enforcement and politics, as well as his role in transforming Inglewood with projects like SoFi Stadium and The Forum.
2. Has James Butts been involved in legal controversies?
Yes, Butts has been involved in multiple legal controversies, including ethical investigations and lawsuits involving former employees and personal conduct issues.
3. How has James Butts contributed to Inglewood’s development?
Butts spearheaded efforts to revitalize Inglewood, attracting major developments such as SoFi Stadium and Intuit Dome, which have boosted the local economy and brought new jobs.
4. What challenges has James Butts faced as mayor?
In addition to legal issues and ethics investigations, Butts has faced criticism for his leadership style, with some describing it as authoritarian. He has also been scrutinized for his handling of city contracts and employee relations.
5. What is James Butts’s background in law enforcement?
James Butts served in various law enforcement roles, including Chief of Police in Santa Monica, where he implemented policies that reduced crime significantly. His career spanned multiple promotions and leadership positions.
In conclusion, James Butts has played a pivotal role in shaping Inglewood’s current landscape, but his career continues to be marred by controversies that raise questions about transparency, accountability, and leadership style. As Inglewood moves forward, Butts’s impact will be seen in both the city’s development achievements and the ethical questions his tenure has brought to light.